+Field test

November 9, 2026

The National Report Said We Ranked for One of Eight Keywords. In Salt Lake City It Was Three. In St. Louis It Was One.

I tracked the same eight remodeling keywords for one multi-location home-service brand nationally and in four of its cities with Semrush Position Tracking. The national view showed one keyword in the top 100. The city views showed a brand that is winning in Salt Lake City and Lincoln, half there in Cincinnati, and nearly invisible in St. Louis. Same website, same day, four different SEO stories.

01The claim

"We rank #4" is missing the only detail that matters: where?

A lot of SEO reports still end with one number per keyword. Position 4. Position 37. Not in the top 100. For a business that sells to one city, that number is roughly fine. For a business that sells in ten cities, it is an average of markets that have almost nothing in common, and it hides both the wins and the problems.

I wanted to see how big the gap actually is for a real client, so I stopped looking at the national number and asked the same question in four cities.

02The setup

One website, eight keywords, five locations, one day

The site belongs to a kitchen and bath remodeling brand I work with that has locations in several states. It already had a national campaign in Semrush Position Tracking, 70 keywords on Google desktop in the United States. I added four city targets to the same project: Cincinnati, St. Louis, Lincoln, and Salt Lake City, all four of them markets the brand serves.

For the cities I tracked the same eight generic keywords, the ones a homeowner types without a brand or a city in them: bathroom remodel near me, bathroom remodeling near me, kitchen remodelers near me, remodeling companies near me, kitchen remodel contractors, bathroom remodel contractors, kitchen and bath remodeling, and one day kitchen and bath. Same keywords, same device, same search engine. The only thing that changed was the location.

Everything below is the November 9 snapshot. One day is a snapshot, not a trend, so treat the positions as directional and the pattern as the point.

03The receipts

The national report and the city reports disagree on almost everything

Nationally, seven of the eight keywords were not in the top 100. The only one that ranked was one day kitchen and bath, at position 4. If that were the only report the owner saw, the takeaway would be that the brand does not show up for generic remodeling searches at all.

In the cities it was a different business.

Salt Lake City: one day kitchen and bath at #1, kitchen and bath remodeling at #3, and kitchen remodelers near me at #3. Three of eight keywords ranking, two of them invisible in the national report. Semrush put the city visibility at 19.02 percent.

Lincoln: one day kitchen and bath at #1 and kitchen and bath remodeling at #3. Visibility 15.76 percent.

Cincinnati: one day kitchen and bath at #1 and kitchen and bath remodeling at #8. Visibility 13.7 percent.

St. Louis: one day kitchen and bath at #3, and nothing else in the top 100. Visibility 3.26 percent, about a sixth of Salt Lake City, for the same brand on the same domain.

Kitchen and bath remodeling is the clearest example of the gap. Not in the top 100 nationally. Position 3 in two cities and position 8 in a third. A national report would call that keyword a failure. In three of the four markets that matter to the business, it is working.

And then the part no report flatters: the bathroom keywords. Bathroom remodel near me, bathroom remodeling near me, and bathroom remodel contractors were not in the top 100 in any of the five locations, national or city. Semrush shows 27,100 national monthly searches for bathroom remodel near me alone. The city views did not just reveal hidden wins. They confirmed that one whole product line is missing everywhere.

04What it means

The national number hid three wins, one problem market, and a missing product line

Under-reported wins. Two of the three keywords ranking in Salt Lake City did not exist in the national report. If you were deciding where to put next quarter's budget from the national view, you would be fixing something that is already fixed.

A market that needs work. St. Louis is not doing what the other three cities do with the same site and the same page templates. That is a market-level problem, not a keyword-level one, and it does not show up at all until you track the city on its own. This brand has more than one St. Louis page on the site, so the first thing I am checking is whether those pages are splitting the signal instead of stacking it.

A content gap. Every city agreed on the bathroom keywords. When four markets fail the same way, the cause is usually on the website, not in the market. The pages that ranked were the city pages and, in Cincinnati, a kitchen remodel page. No bathroom page ranked for a bathroom keyword in any city.

This lines up with something I keep finding from different angles: the useful unit in local SEO is the page and the place, not the domain. I saw the same thing counting AI citations by page in the page-not-domain test, and in the multi-location keyword research piece.

05The playbook

What I would change now that I can see the split

One. Report per city. The owner of a multi-location business should see one row per market, not one national average. In this case the average said almost nothing ranks, and three of the four cities said otherwise.

Two. Copy the winning city. Salt Lake City ranks for kitchen remodelers near me and nobody else does. Before writing anything new, I would compare that city's page to the others: what it covers, how it is linked, what its Google Business Profile looks like. The best brief for the other cities is already live on the same site.

Three. Fix St. Louis as a market, not a keyword. Check for competing pages, check which page Google picks for each keyword, and consolidate if two pages are asking for the same search.

Four. Build the bathroom pages. One real bathroom remodeling page per city, not a bullet on a services page. Every location failed the same three bathroom keywords, so this is the one fix that should move all four cities at once.

Five. Re-run it. One day of positions is a starting line. Keep the city targets on and look again in 30 days, after the changes go live.

06The tooling

How to see your own local rank gap in about ten minutes

In Position Tracking, open your campaign, click the location under the domain name, and choose Add new target. Pick the city, keep the same device and search engine, and for the keyword source choose your existing target so the lists match exactly. Each city you add counts its keywords against your tracking limit, so start with five to ten keywords and the cities that make you money. The first positions came in for me within a few hours.

Then put the city views side by side with the national one. If the national report is the only one your client or your boss sees, they are looking at an average of places they do not sell in. Position Tracking is part of the SEO Toolkit in Semrush One.

07The verdict

Same site, four cities, four different SEO stories

Nationally, this brand ranked for one of eight generic remodeling keywords. In Salt Lake City it ranked for three, in Lincoln and Cincinnati for two, and in St. Louis for one. The national report did not just round off the detail. It pointed at the wrong problem.

So the next time a report says a keyword ranks at #8, ask the follow-up question before anything else: #8 where?

You own a number that isn't moving. Let's move it.